AI-Ready GTM

Turn a competitor's LinkedIn commenters into a lead list

An agency says post commenters make a targeted list. It breaks LinkedIn's rules, so read the risk.

Peter Benei, 10 November 2026

In partnership with

Happy Friday.

Someone in your market posts on LinkedIn and gets 400 comments. Growth Engine X's bet is that those commenters care about your category. Today's cheat code turns them into a list. It's this week's riskiest, and the risk is spelled out below.


Smart starts here.

You don't have to read everything — just the right thing. 1440's daily newsletter distills the day's biggest stories from 100+ sources into one quick, 5-minute read. It's the fastest way to stay sharp, sound informed, and actually understand what's happening in the world. Join 4.5 million readers who start their day the smart way.

Join for free today!


The cheat code: scrape the commenters

What it is. Pull the names of people who comment on posts in your category, keep the ones who fit, and email them. Growth Engine X, a cold email agency, lays out the play and calls people who engage with posts "one of the most targeted lists you can build for outbound." It builds its own scraper; the steps below use a ready-made one.

Part of AI-Ready Media Group, read by 23,000+ marketing leaders.

Free. Unsubscribe any time.

The steps

  1. Pick five people who post about your category: a competitor's founder, an analyst, a well-known voice. Growth Engine X says posts from individuals beat posts from company pages.

  2. Copy the links to their most-commented posts from the last month.

  3. Scrape the commenters. HarvestAPI's LinkedIn Post Comments Scraper on Apify costs $1.50 to $2 per 1,000 comments, by its own page, and its maker says it needs no LinkedIn account or cookies. Apify's free plan gives you $5 a month to spend. PhantomBuster's Post Commenters Export does a similar job at far lower volume: it runs on your own LinkedIn session, its page recommends at most 50 comments a day on a regular account, and it warns it may miss comments on very large posts.

  4. Filter. The scraper gives you each commenter's name, LinkedIn URL and a one-line position. Keep the titles and companies you sell to; full profile data costs extra. Growth Engine X's example cuts 1,000 of those people down to the 200 who fit.

  5. Find emails and send, using the first line under Steal this. Never mention the post. Growth Engine X's warning: "people will screenshot that email" and send it to the person whose post you scraped.

The risk, plainly. This can get an account restricted. LinkedIn's own help page says it doesn't permit any software that will "scrape, modify the appearance of, or automate activity on LinkedIn's website," and that members who use such tools "risk having their accounts restricted or shut down."

The rule makes no exception for a scraper that doesn't log in: LinkedIn also bans copying or using information "obtained from the Services, whether directly or through third parties," without the content owner's consent. HarvestAPI's page claims it doesn't violate platform policies or risk account restrictions. That's the seller talking, and LinkedIn's rules say otherwise. Not handing over your login keeps your own session out of that tool. I can't vouch for how it gets the data, and you're still breaking the rules.

A tool that runs on your login, like PhantomBuster, puts your profile on the line too. PhantomBuster's page says "Stay compliant" and gives two limits: 50 posts a day in one place, 50 comments a day in another. LinkedIn's page gives no safe number.

If you sell into Europe, a scraped list of names is personal data under the GDPR, so check with whoever owns that at your company.

Tools and cost. About $0 to $5 for a first batch on Apify's free credit, plus an email finder. Growth Engine X uses Clay for that step. Clay's free plan has 100 data credits a month, and Clay's own example spends 95 enriching 100 contacts, so that covers about half a batch of 200.

What to expect. Growth Engine X calls it "one of the closest things to a guaranteed playbook in outbound." It sells outbound campaigns and shows no numbers, so treat that as a pitch. Try one batch of 200 and count the replies.


Steal this

Step 5 says never mention the post, so what do you open with? One real fact. Christian, founder of the outbound agency Pipeline, posted on Oct 22 that his AI-written personal first lines got a 0.27% reply rate, and a campaign using "one real detail from the prospect's business (their project and location) hit 14.5%." His agency's own numbers. Try this line: "Saw [COMPANY] is [REAL PROJECT] in [LOCATION]. [ONE QUESTION ABOUT IT]?"


Tool Review → Lemlist

Lemlist sends cold email sequences and includes an email and phone finder, email warm-up and a lead database. The Email plan is $69 a month, or $55 billed yearly, for 50,000 emails a month. Multichannel is $109 a month, or $87 billed yearly.

An outbound team could find the addresses and send from one tool, which covers the email-finder step above. The catch: Multichannel adds LinkedIn automation, and today's risk section applies to that too.

Worth it if you send cold email every week. Skip it if you send a handful: at $55 a month, Gmail and a spreadsheet will do.

→ Try Lemlist


Tool Hack: give the real detail its own column

  1. Add a column called icebreaker to your CSV. Write one line per lead, using the "Saw [COMPANY] is..." line above.

  2. Import the CSV into your campaign. On "Set up imported fields," check the column is linked to the icebreaker field.

  3. In your email step, open the variable menu and add icebreaker right after the greeting.

  4. Click Preview and check a few leads. Lemlist says the raw variable can show up as literal text when a cell is empty, so fill every row before you send.


That's the week. Which of the five are you trying first?


Also send me

Part of AI-Ready Media Group, read by 23,000+ marketing leaders.

Free. Unsubscribe any time.

More issues

More from AI-Ready Media Group

AI-Ready GTM

Daily newsletter on AI-powered go-to-market: one lead gen, outreach, sales or ABM play you can try.

Also send me

Part of AI-Ready Media Group, read by 23,000+ marketing leaders.

Free. Unsubscribe any time.